FTL Somalia
Guudlaawe certificate Election Hirshabelle

Guudlaawe Faces a Malxiis Opposition as Hirshabelle Presidential Election Proceeds

JOWHAR, Hirshabelle’s regional parliament is voting today to elect the state’s president and vice president, with incumbent Ali Abdullahi Hussein Guudlaawe widely expected to secure a second term despite unresolved grievances from the Hiiraan region over the power-sharing arrangement that governs the federal member state.

Four candidates are contesting the two positions. Guudlaawe, representing the Justice and Solidarity Party (JSP), faces Nur Ilmi Halane of the Ramaas party for the presidency. For the vice presidency, Abdifatah Hassan Afrah of JSP is competing against Abdifatah Baashi Mohamed of the Iftiin Qaran party.

The outcome is effectively predetermined. The JSP holds 78 of the 99 seats in the regional assembly, following the September 30 parliamentary elections that marked the first direct vote in Hirshabelle’s history. With that majority, Guudlaawe’s re-election is assured, and Afrah’s selection as his deputy is equally certain. In Somali political slang, the opposing candidates from Ramaas and Iftiin Qaran are widely viewed as a malxiis, a term borrowed from the traditional role of the groom’s best man. Just as the malxiis stands beside the groom to ensure the wedding goes smoothly, these candidates stand beside Guudlaawe to provide a veneer of democratic competition for a ceremony whose outcome is already decided.

The Hiiraan Question

The procedural certainty of today’s vote does not reflect political consensus. The JSP’s decision to renominate Guudlaawe, an Abgaal from Middle Shabelle, has deepened a long-running dispute with the Hawadle community of Hiiraan, who argue that the presidency should rotate to their region under the power-sharing formula that created Hirshabelle in 2016.

Hirshabelle Vice President Yusuf Ahmed Hagar Dabageed, a Hawadle politician, has publicly accused President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud of reneging on a promise to return the regional presidency to the Hawadle clan. According to Dabageed, when he asked the president about his own candidacy, Hassan Sheikh replied that he would give the position to Guudlaawe instead.

Prior to the parliamentary vote, Dabageed warned that elections could not proceed in Hiiraan without a political agreement involving traditional elders and local stakeholders. While voting did take place in Beledweyne, the underlying grievances remain unresolved.

The JSP’s selection of Afrah, a former Hiiraan governor, as the vice-presidential candidate was intended to balance the ticket and address Hawadle concerns. But the arrangement does not satisfy the community’s demand for the presidency itself.

What Comes Next

Guudlaawe’s new administration will inherit a state with persistent security challenges, including Al-Shabaab activity in rural areas, and unresolved political tensions that have periodically disrupted governance in Beledweyne. The Hawadle community’s sense of exclusion, articulated by the outgoing vice president and supported by traditional elders, will not disappear because the parliamentary arithmetic favors the JSP.

As reported in FTL Somalia’s coverage of the electoral timetable, the compressed schedule that produced today’s vote left little room for the kind of consensus-building that Hiiraan stakeholders have demanded. The new administration will take office with a mandate that is legally valid but politically contested.

Critical Note

Today’s vote in Jowhar is a procedural formality. The JSP’s two-thirds majority in the regional assembly means that Guudlaawe and Afrah will be elected regardless of the token opposition from Ramaas and Iftiin Qaran. The real contest is not between candidates. It is between the federal government’s strategy of installing allied administrations across the federal member states and the grievances of communities that feel excluded from that strategy.

The presence of malxiis candidates on the ballot does not make the election competitive. It makes it performative. The Hiiraan dispute is not a peripheral complaint. It speaks to the foundational bargain that created Hirshabelle, an informal power-sharing arrangement that allocated the presidency to the Hawadle but was broken when Guudlaawe, an Abgaal, won in 2020. The JSP’s decision to renominate Guudlaawe, and the federal government’s overt backing of his candidacy, confirms that the arrangement has been abandoned in practice.

Guudlaawe will govern with a parliament that supports him and a federal government that sponsors him. Whether he can govern with the consent of Hiiraan’s political establishment is a different question. The answer will determine whether Hirshabelle’s next administration is stable or simply another chapter in the cycle of contested leadership that has defined the state since its formation.